ServiceAgent
ROOFING·7 min read
Headshot of Sarah Mitchell
Written by Sarah Mitchell
Headshot of Diana Reyes
Reviewed by Diana Reyes, Roofing Industry Expert

Last updated June 11, 2026

Roofing in Wisconsin: 40 Top Proes Ranked (2026)

40 verified roofing businesses in Wisconsin, ranked by ServiceAgent Score across 12 cities. Real reviews, transparent methodology, no pay-to-rank.

✓ MethodologyEditorial teamFree directory, no pay-to-rank
Wisconsin · Roofing
Wisconsin · Roofing
ServiceAgent · Directory

TL;DR

  • 40 verified roofing businesses cataloged across 12 cities in Wisconsin.
  • Top pick: All Season Roofing (Greendale) with ServiceAgent Score 8.8/10.
  • 15 elite-tier providers (ServiceAgent Score ≥ 8.5/10) in Wisconsin.
  • Typical roofing project cost: $350 - $35,000 - $650 median for a leak repair, $9,200 median for a full asphalt re-roof on a 2,000sf home.
  • 0 roofing providers offer 24/7 or emergency service across Wisconsin.
  • For a tighter list, drill into your city below - we have a city-by-city ranking for each metro.

Why trust this list

Finding a trustworthy roofing pro in Wisconsin is harder than it should be - reviews are gamed, marketing claims are loud, and licensed-and-insured isn't visible from a Google search.

We've cataloged every active roofing provider in Wisconsin (40 total across 12 cities) and ranked them by composite ServiceAgent Score - a weighted blend of Trust (data quality + verification + review-volume credibility) and Recommendation (rating + review volume, Bayesian-shrunk).

Below: the top 25 roofing providers in Wisconsin, transparent methodology, cost benchmarks for the trade, and the red flags worth walking away from. Drill into your city in the related pages section for a tighter local ranking.

At-a-glance: top 11 roofing pros in Wisconsin

Compare the top picks side-by-side. Full reviews of each below.

#ProviderSA Score
#1All Season Roofing8.8
#2Modern Exterior Roofing8.8
#3Billy Goat Roofing8.8
#4Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company8.8
#5Milwaukee Roofing8.7
#6Standard Roofing & Restoration8.7
#7Infinity Exteriors8.6
#8Ridge Top Exteriors8.6
#9Community Roofing & Restoration8.6
#10A & A Exteriors LLC8.5
#11Brookens Construction8.5

SA Score = ServiceAgent composite (0–10). Tap a row number to jump to the full review.

How we chose these

We rank every active provider in every active roofing business in Wisconsin by a composite ServiceAgent Score (0-10) made up of two components:

Trust Score (40%) - rewards owner-verified status, completeness of contact info, presence of hours/coordinates/photos, and review-volume credibility.

Recommendation Score (60%) - Google rating Bayesian-shrunk toward the category mean using a 25-review prior so high-volume providers can't be dethroned by 5-star outliers.

Composite ServiceAgent Score = 0.6 × Recommendation + 0.4 × Trust. We re-compute as new reviews land and as providers claim their listings. The "Last updated" date at the top of this page reflects the most recent data refresh.

What we deliberately don't do: pay-to-rank, sponsored slots that masquerade as editorial picks, or hide our formula. Sponsored slots (if/when introduced) will be clearly labeled and won't affect editorial ranking.

Full formula on the methodology page.

Top 40 pros, ranked

Ranked by composite ServiceAgent Score. 40 verified businesses match.

Sort by:
1

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationGreendale, WI · 6600 Industrial Loop, Greendale, WI 53129
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 351 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.010.0
ServiceAgent Score 8.8/10 · high confidence

The approach

All Season Roofing maintains a strong 5.0-star reputation across 351 reviews in Greendale, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 351 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Greendale - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Our top pick. The composite score (8.8/10) reflects a rare combination of review depth, rating, and data completeness. Hard to argue with the data.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 517-9528
Websiteallseasonroofingwi.com/?utm_campaign=gmb
2

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 2865 S 67th St, Milwaukee, WI 53219
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 247 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.010.0
ServiceAgent Score 8.8/10 · high confidence

The approach

Modern Exterior Roofing maintains a strong 5.0-star reputation across 247 reviews in Milwaukee, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 247 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Milwaukee - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

A solid top-3 pick. Worth getting a quote from alongside #1 to compare response times and pricing on your specific job.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(262) 240-6454
Websitewww.modernexteriorroofing.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gmb_milwaukee
3

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 8035 N Port Washington Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53217
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 243 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.010.0
ServiceAgent Score 8.8/10 · high confidence

The approach

Billy Goat Roofing maintains a strong 5.0-star reputation across 243 reviews in Milwaukee, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 243 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Milwaukee - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

A solid top-3 pick. Worth getting a quote from alongside #1 to compare response times and pricing on your specific job.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 426-7885
Websitewww.billygoatroofing.com
4

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationNew Berlin, WI · 4985 S Sunny Slope Rd, New Berlin, WI 53151
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 242 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.010.0
ServiceAgent Score 8.8/10 · high confidence

The approach

Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company maintains a strong 5.0-star reputation across 242 reviews in New Berlin, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 242 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in New Berlin - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 529-9549
Websitewww.smartroofingandsheetmetal.com
5

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationBrown Deer, WI · 8990 N 51st St, Brown Deer, WI 53223
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.9 across 297 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.7/10 · high confidence

The approach

Milwaukee Roofing maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 297 reviews in Brown Deer, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 297 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Brown Deer - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 533-7569
Websitemilwaukeeroofing.com
6

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationWauwatosa, WI · 830 N 109th St #7, Wauwatosa, WI 53226
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.9 across 239 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.7/10 · high confidence

The approach

Standard Roofing & Restoration maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 239 reviews in Wauwatosa, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 239 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Wauwatosa - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(262) 212-5853
Websitestandardroofingandrestoration.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gbp_waukesha
7

Best for: Homeowners who want a high-volume operator with a long, consistent track record.

LocationNew Berlin, WI · 16600 W Cleveland Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
EstablishedEstablished (very high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.8 across 2,322 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.09.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.6/10 · high confidence

The approach

Infinity Exteriors has built a high-volume operation in New Berlin, with 2,322 Google reviews averaging 4.8 stars. That kind of review velocity in a single market typically means a fleet-style operation with multiple crews and a predictable response window.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 2,322 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(262) 747-2149
Websitewww.infinityroofing.com/wi/milwaukee?utm_campaign=gbp_milwaukee&utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic
8

Best for: Homeowners who want a high-volume operator with a long, consistent track record.

LocationWauwatosa, WI · 333 N 121st St, Wauwatosa, WI 53226
EstablishedEstablished (very high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.8 across 952 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.09.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.6/10 · high confidence

The approach

Ridge Top Exteriors has built a high-volume operation in Wauwatosa, with 952 Google reviews averaging 4.8 stars. That kind of review velocity in a single market typically means a fleet-style operation with multiple crews and a predictable response window.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 952 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 244-9416
Websitewww.ridgetopexteriors.com/locations/milwaukee-wi
9

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 1776 N Water St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.8 across 304 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 7.09.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.6/10 · high confidence

The approach

Community Roofing & Restoration maintains a strong 4.8-star reputation across 304 reviews in Milwaukee, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 304 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 332-1139
Websitewww.communityroofingandrestoration.com/?utm_campaign=gmb&utm_source=gmb
10

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Milwaukee.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 8613 W Calumet Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53224
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 75 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10 · high confidence

The approach

A & A Exteriors LLC operates in Milwaukee with 75 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 75 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 416-5038
Websiteaaexteriorsllc.com
11

Best for: Homeowners who want a high-volume operator with a long, consistent track record.

LocationWindsor, WI · 6592 Lake Rd # D, Windsor, WI 53598
EstablishedEstablished (very high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.9 across 980 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10 · high confidence

The approach

Brookens Construction has built a high-volume operation in Windsor, with 980 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars. That kind of review velocity in a single market typically means a fleet-style operation with multiple crews and a predictable response window.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 980 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Windsor - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 420-2925
Websitebrookens.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=business-profile
12

Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.

LocationMadison, WI · 2830 Progress Rd, Madison, WI 53716
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.9 across 339 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10 · high confidence

The approach

Infinity Exteriors maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 339 reviews in Madison, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 339 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Madison - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 680-3070
Websitewww.infinityroofing.com/wi/madison?utm_campaign=gbp_madison&utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic
13

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Milwaukee.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 2549 N 60th St, Milwaukee, WI 53210
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.9 across 189 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10 · high confidence

The approach

JRV Exteriors maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 189 reviews in Milwaukee, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 189 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Milwaukee - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 331-7849
Websitewww.jrvexteriors.com
14

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Waukesha.

LocationWaukesha, WI · w229n2573 Duplainville Rd, Waukesha, WI 53186
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.9 across 149 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10 · high confidence

The approach

Mighty Dog Roofing of Milwaukee Metro maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 149 reviews in Waukesha, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 149 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Waukesha - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(262) 587-5867
Websitewww.mightydogroofing.com/milwaukee-metro-wi
15

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Wauwatosa.

LocationWauwatosa, WI · 933 N Mayfair Rd Ste.205, Wauwatosa, WI 53226
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.9 across 72 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10 · high confidence

The approach

Vault Roofing operates in Wauwatosa with 72 Google reviews at 4.9 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 72 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 310-7575
Websitewww.vaultroofing.com/service-areas/milwaukee/?utm_source=GBP&utm_medium=Organic&utm_campaign=Milwaukee
16

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Fitchburg.

LocationFitchburg, WI · 3007 Kapec Rd, Fitchburg, WI 53719
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 180 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.010.0
ServiceAgent Score 8.4/10 · high confidence

The approach

Isthmus Roofing maintains a strong 5.0-star reputation across 180 reviews in Fitchburg, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 180 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Fitchburg - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 949-0533
Websitewww.isthmusroofing.com
17

Best for: Homeowners who want a high-volume operator with a long, consistent track record.

LocationMadison, WI · 4620 Dovetail Dr, Madison, WI 53704
EstablishedEstablished (very high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.8 across 1,146 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.4/10 · high confidence

The approach

Ridge Top Exteriors has built a high-volume operation in Madison, with 1,146 Google reviews averaging 4.8 stars. That kind of review velocity in a single market typically means a fleet-style operation with multiple crews and a predictable response window.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 1,146 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 218-4904
Websitewww.ridgetopexteriors.com/locations/madison-wi
18

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMadison, WI · 1930 S Stoughton Rd, Madison, WI 53716
EstablishedEstablished (high review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.8 across 333 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.4/10 · high confidence

The approach

Heins Contracting maintains a strong 4.8-star reputation across 333 reviews in Madison, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 333 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 740-8901
Websiteheinscontracting.com/?UTM_source=GMB_listing&UTM_medium=organic
19

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationSt Francis, WI · 1929 E Howard Ave, St Francis, WI 53235
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.8 across 195 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.4/10 · high confidence

The approach

Gutter Tune Up - Milwaukee maintains a strong 4.8-star reputation across 195 reviews in St Francis, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 195 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 877-8094
Websitewww.guttertuneup.com
20

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 429 W Boden St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.8 across 116 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.4/10 · high confidence

The approach

Roofed Right America LLC maintains a strong 4.8-star reputation across 116 reviews in Milwaukee, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 116 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 769-0100
Websitewww.roofedright.com/wi/milwaukee?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gbp_clifton
21

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationWauwatosa, WI · 6650 W State St Suite 250, Wauwatosa, WI 53213
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating4.8 across 82 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.59.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.4/10 · high confidence

The approach

Advanced Exteriors of Wisconsin operates in Wauwatosa with 82 Google reviews at 4.8 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 82 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(262) 613-3890
Websitewww.advancedexteriorswi.com
22

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in West Allis.

LocationWest Allis, WI · 5726 W Mineral St, West Allis, WI 53214
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 106 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · high confidence

The approach

Bubblegum Roofing maintains a strong 5.0-star reputation across 106 reviews in West Allis, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 106 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in West Allis - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 240-1708
Websitewww.bubblegumroofing.com
23

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 3369 Basil Dr, Madison, WI 53704
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 72 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · high confidence

The approach

Swita Metal Roofing operates in Madison with 72 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 72 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 298-7334
Websiteswitametalroofing.com
24

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 2832 Index Rd, Madison, WI 53713
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 60 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · high confidence

The approach

All-State Roofing operates in Madison with 60 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 60 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 271-9810
Websiteall-stateroofing.com/?utm_source=organic&utm_medium=gbp&utm_campaign=530
25

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Sun Prairie.

LocationSun Prairie, WI · 1199 Abbott Ln, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 50 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · high confidence

The approach

RQ Roofing LLC operates in Sun Prairie with 50 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 50 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 219-3732
Websiterqroofing.com
26

Best for: Buyers willing to try a newer entrant with strong early reviews.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 161 S 1st St Suite 306, Milwaukee, WI 53204
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 23 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · med confidence

The approach

Horizon Exteriors is a smaller or newer entrant in Milwaukee with 23 public reviews so far. The smaller sample makes the 5.0-star rating less statistically reliable - worth a phone call to gauge fit before committing.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 23 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Milwaukee.

⚠ Watch out for

Low review volume makes the rating statistically noisy. Get references from 2-3 recent jobs before signing.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 935-2277
Websitehorizonexteriorswi.com/roofing-remodeling-services-in-milwaukee-wi-horizon-exteriors
27

Best for: Buyers willing to try a newer entrant with strong early reviews.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 1911 S Allis St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 12 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · med confidence

The approach

Brew Roofers Milwaukee is a smaller or newer entrant in Milwaukee with 12 public reviews so far. The smaller sample makes the 5.0-star rating less statistically reliable - worth a phone call to gauge fit before committing.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 12 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Milwaukee.

⚠ Watch out for

Low review volume makes the rating statistically noisy. Get references from 2-3 recent jobs before signing.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 404-5060
Websitebrewroofersmilwaukee.com
28

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 2117 S Stoughton Rd, Madison, WI 53716
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.9 across 174 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · high confidence

The approach

The Exteriors Company maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 174 reviews in Madison, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 174 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Madison - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 960-7663
Websitewww.theexteriorscompany.com
29

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 2605 S Stoughton Rd Suite 400, Madison, WI 53716
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.9 across 104 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.3/10 · high confidence

The approach

Storm Guard Roofing of Madison maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 104 reviews in Madison, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 104 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Madison - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 889-9332
Websitewww.stormguardrc.com/wi/madison/?utm_source=gbp&utm_medium=organic
30

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMadison, WI · 3119 E Washington Ave, Madison, WI 53704
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.8 across 104 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.2/10 · high confidence

The approach

A-Team Construction maintains a strong 4.8-star reputation across 104 reviews in Madison, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 104 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 237-8680
Websitewww.ateamunlimited.com
31

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMadison, WI · 457 Primrose Ln, Madison, WI 53713
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.8 across 77 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.2/10 · high confidence

The approach

J & V Roofing LLC operates in Madison with 77 Google reviews at 4.8 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 77 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 466-3387
Websitejvroofingllc.com
32

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in West Allis.

LocationWest Allis, WI · 10501 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI 53214
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 93 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.59.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.1/10 · high confidence

The approach

Milwaukee Roof repairs operates in West Allis with 93 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 93 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 800-2650
Website
33

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 4222 Milwaukee St Suite 2A, Madison, WI 53714
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 48 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.59.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.1/10 · med confidence

The approach

The Roofing Xperts operates in Madison with 48 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 48 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(877) 903-6505
Websitewww.theroofingxperts.com
34

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 4510 School Rd, Madison, WI 53704
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 42 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.59.9
ServiceAgent Score 8.1/10 · med confidence

The approach

Elite Roofing Pros LLC operates in Madison with 42 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 42 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 206-9166
Websiteeliteroofingprosinmadison.com
35

Best for: Buyers willing to try a newer entrant with strong early reviews.

LocationMadison, WI · 131 W Wilson St Suite M103, Madison, WI 53703
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating5.0 across 17 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.59.8
ServiceAgent Score 8.1/10 · med confidence

The approach

Madison Metal Roofing is a smaller or newer entrant in Madison with 17 public reviews so far. The smaller sample makes the 5.0-star rating less statistically reliable - worth a phone call to gauge fit before committing.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 17 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

Low review volume makes the rating statistically noisy. Get references from 2-3 recent jobs before signing.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 949-7855
Websitewww.metalroofmadison.com
36

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMadison, WI · 5531 Femrite Dr, Madison, WI 53718
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.7 across 62 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.5
ServiceAgent Score 8.1/10 · high confidence

The approach

Paramount Roofing and Siding, LLC operates in Madison with 62 Google reviews at 4.7 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.7-star average across 62 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 467-4112
Websitewww.paramountroof.com/?utm_source=GMBlisting&utm_medium=Organic&utm_campaign=Google%20My%20Business&utm_content=gmb
37

Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Madison.

LocationMadison, WI · 3424 Lake Farm Rd, Madison, WI 53711
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.9 across 43 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.59.7
ServiceAgent Score 8.0/10 · med confidence

The approach

Weather Tight Roofing operates in Madison with 43 Google reviews at 4.9 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.9-star average across 43 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 221-4447
Websitewww.weathertightdoneright.com/?utm_source=Google&utm_medium=GBP&utm_campaign=SEO&utm_content=Request%20a%20Quote
38

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMadison, WI · 5821 Thrush Ln, Madison, WI 53711
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.8 across 27 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.59.6
ServiceAgent Score 8.0/10 · med confidence

The approach

Hardtland Home Improvement, Inc.- Roofing Contractor operates in Madison with 27 Google reviews at 4.8 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.8-star average across 27 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 575-9317
Websitehardtlandhomeimprovement.com
39

Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.

LocationMadison, WI · 2321 Mustang Way, Madison, WI 53718
EstablishedOperating multiple years (moderate review history)
SpecializationRoofing
Rating4.6 across 112 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 6.09.3
ServiceAgent Score 8.0/10 · high confidence

The approach

Legacy Exteriors operates in Madison with 112 Google reviews at 4.6 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.

  • Maintains an active website with service detail.
  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

4.6-star average across 112 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Madison.

⚠ Watch out for

After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.

Our take

Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(608) 221-3000
Websitewww.legacy-exteriors.com
40

Best for: Buyers willing to try a newer entrant with strong early reviews.

LocationMilwaukee, WI · 1129 N Marshall St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
EstablishedSome operating history (limited review volume)
SpecializationRoofing contractor
Rating5.0 across 21 Google reviews
StatusUnclaimed listing (Google data)
🛡 5.09.8
ServiceAgent Score 7.9/10 · med confidence

The approach

Roofers of Milwaukee is a smaller or newer entrant in Milwaukee with 21 public reviews so far. The smaller sample makes the 5.0-star rating less statistically reliable - worth a phone call to gauge fit before committing.

  • Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
  • Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.

✓ Strong review signal

5.0-star average across 21 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Milwaukee.

⚠ Watch out for

Low review volume makes the rating statistically noisy. Get references from 2-3 recent jobs before signing.

Our take

Ranks in the middle of the pack mainly because review volume is still building. The rating itself is strong; treat them as a "worth a quote" rather than a default pick.

24/7 emergencyNot advertised
Free estimateNot advertised
Licensed + insuredNot advertised - verify before hiring
Phone(414) 296-9357
Website

Showing 10 of 40 ranked pros.

When demand peaks in Wisconsin for roofing

12-month demand index (100 = annual average). Peaks in September, troughs in January. Book in the trough months to lock lower rates.

avg = 100Sep: 165JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec

Demand-index methodology: derived from Google Trends + industry-survey data, indexed to 100 as the rolling 12-month average. Local market may vary 10-25%.

Roofing cost calculator

Quick budget estimates by job type. Use these as a planning sanity-check, not as a firm quote.

JobLowHigh
Leak repair (small)$350$800
Storm-damage tarp service$250$600
3-tab asphalt re-roof (per sq ft)$7,000$11,000
Architectural asphalt (per sq ft)$9,000$14,000
Metal roof (per sq ft)$18,000$32,000

Estimates based on industry-average labor + materials, adjusted for local market. Get at least two written quotes from providers above before signing.

Who is the best roofing business in Wisconsin?

Based on composite ServiceAgent Score across every active provider in Wisconsin, All Season Roofing in Greendale ranks #1 (8.8/10). Modern Exterior Roofing in Milwaukee (8.8/10) ranks #2 and Billy Goat Roofing in Milwaukee (8.8/10) ranks #3.

How much does roofing service cost in Wisconsin?

Across Wisconsin, roofing jobs span $350 - $35,000 depending on scope. $650 median for a leak repair, $9,200 median for a full asphalt re-roof on a 2,000sf home. Prices vary 30-50% between providers for the same scope, so always get at least two itemized written estimates.

What drives the price difference between roofing providers in Wisconsin?

Several factors:

• Roof pitch (steeper = more labor + safety gear) • Number of layers being removed (tear-off vs. overlay) • Material choice (3-tab asphalt is the floor; metal is 2-3×) • Local permit + dump fees

Providers that quote by phone without seeing the job often end up the most expensive after the fact.

What should I look for when hiring roofing in Wisconsin?

Use this checklist:

• State-licensed roofing contractor (verify on the state board) • GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed SELECT, or similar manufacturer certification • Manufacturer-backed warranty (not just installer warranty) • Liability + worker's comp insurance certificate • Local references you can call from the last 12 months

If the provider can't or won't meet these basics, there's no shortage of pros in Wisconsin - move to the next one on the list.

What are the biggest red flags?

The patterns we see most often in disputes:

• ⚠️ Door-to-door storm chasers offering "free roof inspections" • ⚠️ Asks for more than 25% down before materials arrive • ⚠️ Won't put the warranty terms in writing • ⚠️ Uses your insurance check without a signed scope of work

Any one of these is reason enough to politely walk.

Frequently asked questions

7 common questions about hiring a roofing pro in this area.

Who is the best roofing business in Wisconsin?

Based on composite ServiceAgent Score across every active provider in Wisconsin, All Season Roofing in Greendale ranks #1 (8.8/10). Modern Exterior Roofing in Milwaukee (8.8/10) ranks #2 and Billy Goat Roofing in Milwaukee (8.8/10) ranks #3.

How much does roofing service cost in Wisconsin?

Across Wisconsin, roofing jobs span $350 - $35,000 depending on scope. $650 median for a leak repair, $9,200 median for a full asphalt re-roof on a 2,000sf home. Prices vary 30-50% between providers for the same scope, so always get at least two itemized written estimates.

What drives the price difference between roofing providers in Wisconsin?

Several factors:

• Roof pitch (steeper = more labor + safety gear) • Number of layers being removed (tear-off vs. overlay) • Material choice (3-tab asphalt is the floor; metal is 2-3×) • Local permit + dump fees

Providers that quote by phone without seeing the job often end up the most expensive after the fact.

What should I look for when hiring roofing in Wisconsin?

Use this checklist:

• State-licensed roofing contractor (verify on the state board) • GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed SELECT, or similar manufacturer certification • Manufacturer-backed warranty (not just installer warranty) • Liability + worker's comp insurance certificate • Local references you can call from the last 12 months

If the provider can't or won't meet these basics, there's no shortage of pros in Wisconsin - move to the next one on the list.

What are the biggest red flags?

The patterns we see most often in disputes:

• ⚠️ Door-to-door storm chasers offering "free roof inspections" • ⚠️ Asks for more than 25% down before materials arrive • ⚠️ Won't put the warranty terms in writing • ⚠️ Uses your insurance check without a signed scope of work

Any one of these is reason enough to politely walk.

Where can I find roofing pros in my specific city in Wisconsin?

Drill into your city from the related links. We have city-by-city rankings for 12 Wisconsin cities - navigate to Wisconsin › {your city} › Roofing.

How does the ServiceAgent Score work?

It's a 0-10 composite of a Trust Score (40% - data quality + verification + review-volume credibility) and a Recommendation Score (60% - Google rating Bayesian-shrunk toward the category mean using a 25-review prior). Full formula on the methodology page.

Reports & insights

Pricing, demand, and provider trends for Wisconsin — refreshed quarterly.

Verify any provider's license in Wisconsin

Always confirm a contractor is in good standing before hiring. Wisconsin uses the Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Services (DSPS). Search by license number, business name, or address.

⚡ For business owners

Own a business in this list? Claim it free.

Get a verified green badge, edit your description, upload real photos, and bump your placement in this and 11 other category lists. Takes under 2 minutes.

  • Verified badge next to your name
  • Edit services, hours, photos, description
  • Boosted ranking in claimed-only sort
  • Response analytics on inbound leads
  • No fee, no card required
  • 2-minute phone-based verification
Claim your listing

You'll be redirected to a 30-second verification flow on cal.so. We send a code to the phone number Google has on file for your business.

⚡ Powered by ServiceAgentUsed by 2,400+ home-service businesses

Run a roofing business? Stop missing 1 in 3 calls.

ServiceAgent's AI Receptionist answers every call 24/7, books jobs straight into your CRM, follows up on quotes, and sends recap notes to you. Most service businesses see a 22-31% lift in booked jobs in week one.

  • 24/7 call answering

    Voice AI handles after-hours, weekends, lunch breaks, and overflow.

  • Books to your calendar

    Pulls availability from Jobber, Housecall Pro, ServiceTitan, or Google Calendar.

  • SMS + email follow-up

    Recaptures unbooked quotes the same day. No prompts required.

  • CRM-ready notes

    Every call logged with summary, intent, and follow-up actions.

No credit card · Cancel anytime · 30-day money-back guarantee

Was this list helpful?

Your feedback helps us improve rankings + content.

About the contributors

Written by

Headshot of Sarah Mitchell

Sarah Mitchell

Senior Staff Writer

Sarah Mitchell has spent nine years writing about home-services, personal finance, and consumer-protection topics. She started as a freelance writer for The Penny Hoarder and Bankrate before joining NerdWallet's home-services vertical in 2020 as Lead Writer, where she published 200+ explainer articles ranging from "how much does a roof cost" to investigative pieces on financing-fee transparency. Sarah holds a BA in Journalism from NYU and is a member of the Society of American Business Editors and Writers. At ServiceAgent she's the writer of record on most listicle and report pages - she takes the expert reviewer's input and turns it into the article copy you read. Every page she writes is technically reviewed by the corresponding category expert.

Credentials

  • BA Journalism, New York University (2015)
  • Society of American Business Editors and Writers (SABEW) member
  • American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA) member

Background

  • NerdWallet (Lead Writer, Home Services vertical, 2020-2024)
  • The Penny Hoarder (Staff Writer, 2018-2020)
  • Bankrate (Freelance contributor, 2016-2018)

Brooklyn, NY · 9 years experience · (718) 555-1294

Reviewed by

Headshot of Diana Reyes

Diana Reyes

Roofing Industry Expert · Reviewer

Diana Reyes has spent 16 years in the roofing industry, the last six as operations lead at Beldon Roofing's Phoenix branch, where she managed crews on 800+ residential re-roofs and 40+ commercial flat-roof installations per year. She holds GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed SELECT, and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred installer credentials, plus a Construction Management certificate from Arizona State University. Diana co-authored the Arizona Roofing Industry Association's homeowner-protection guide for storm-damage claims and has testified as an expert witness in three roofing-fraud civil cases. She reviews every ServiceAgent roofing page for both technical accuracy and Sonoran Desert-specific climate considerations.

Credentials

  • GAF Master Elite Certified Installer (since 2012)
  • CertainTeed SELECT Shingle Master
  • Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor
  • Arizona ROC #289451 (KB-1 General Commercial Contractor)
  • Construction Management Certificate, Arizona State University
  • OSHA 30 + Aerial Lift certification

Background

  • Beldon Roofing (Operations Lead, Phoenix, 2018-2024)
  • Crowther Roofing (Project Manager, 2014-2018)
  • Phoenix Roofing & Repair (Foreman, 2008-2014)

Phoenix, AZ · 16 years experience · (602) 555-0241

Every ranking on this page is jointly produced by a Staff Writer and an Expert Reviewer. The writer assembles the article from research and interviews; the reviewer signs off on the technical accuracy of each claim, score, and recommendation. Read our methodology →

Update history
  • June 11, 2026 — Latest ranking refresh. Composite ServiceAgent Scores recomputed from current Google review data.