Replacement Roofing in Rochester, New York: 15 Top Pros (2026)
15 verified replacement roofing providers in Rochester, ranked by ServiceAgent Score. Full tear-off + new roof. Compare response times, ratings, and pricing - and request a quote in minutes.
TL;DR
- 15 replacement roofing providers match in Rochester, New York.
- Top pick: Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration (ServiceAgent Score 8.5/10).
- Median ServiceAgent Score: 8.2/10.
- 0 owner-verified listings.
- Filtered for Replacement: full tear-off + new roof.
Why trust this list
This page narrows the full Rochester roofing directory to providers that explicitly serve replacement requests. We surfaced them by scanning provider categories, service tags, and review text for relevant signals.
If you're looking at this page, you probably need replacement roofing now - so we've ordered the list by composite ServiceAgent Score and surfaced the response-time indicator on every card. Call the top three; the first to pick up usually wins the job.
At-a-glance: top 11 roofing pros in Rochester
Compare the top picks side-by-side. Full reviews of each below.
SA Score = ServiceAgent composite (0–10). Tap a row number to jump to the full review.
How we chose these
Same scoring engine as the main Rochester roofing ranking, with an additional filter step: we look for Replacement signals in each provider's business categories, service tags, and recent review text.
When the Replacement filter would surface fewer than five providers, we fall back to showing top-rated roofing pros generally - they are far more likely to handle replacement work than an unrated provider would be.
Full formula on the methodology page.
15 Best Roofing Companies Ranked
Ranked by composite ServiceAgent Score. 15 verified businesses match.
Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 115 Fairfax Rd, Rochester, NY 14609 |
|---|---|
| Established | Established (high review volume) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.9★ across 321 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 321 reviews in Rochester, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.9-star average across 321 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Rochester - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Our top pick. The composite score (8.5/10) reflects a rare combination of review depth, rating, and data completeness. Hard to argue with the data.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 467-6767 |
| Website | www.bestroofingcompanyofrochester.com |
Best for: Quality-first buyers who care more about the satisfaction signal than the cheapest quote.
| Location | Rochester, NY · Second Floor, 485 Titus Ave Suite F2, Rochester, NY 14617 |
|---|---|
| Established | Established (high review volume) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.9★ across 254 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Morreall & Company maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 254 reviews in Rochester, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.9-star average across 254 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Rochester - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
A solid top-3 pick. Worth getting a quote from alongside #1 to compare response times and pricing on your specific job.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 204-2005 |
| Website | www.morreallandcompany.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=gbp&utm_campaign=through_gmb |
Best for: Homeowners who want a high-volume operator with a long, consistent track record.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 500 Trolley Blvd, Rochester, NY 14606 |
|---|---|
| Established | Established (very high review volume) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.8★ across 1,348 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Stellar Roofing has built a high-volume operation in Rochester, with 1,348 Google reviews averaging 4.8 stars. That kind of review velocity in a single market typically means a fleet-style operation with multiple crews and a predictable response window.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.8-star average across 1,348 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
A solid top-3 pick. Worth getting a quote from alongside #1 to compare response times and pricing on your specific job.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 888-7663 |
| Website | stellarroofing.com |
Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Rochester.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 40 Edwards Deming Dr, Rochester, NY 14606 |
|---|---|
| Established | Operating multiple years (moderate review history) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.9★ across 128 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Rochester Pro Roofing maintains a strong 4.9-star reputation across 128 reviews in Rochester, suggesting consistent execution rather than a one-off lucky streak.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.9-star average across 128 reviews is in the top 5% of providers in Rochester - unusually high satisfaction signal at this volume.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 505-8000 |
| Website | rochesterproroofing.com |
Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Rochester.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 1742 Long Pond Rd Suite 2, Rochester, NY 14606 |
|---|---|
| Established | Operating multiple years (moderate review history) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 5.0★ across 88 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Tall Pines Roofing Inc. operates in Rochester with 88 Google reviews at 5.0 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
5.0-star average across 88 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 441-4272 |
| Website | tallpinesroofing.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gbp |
Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Rochester.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 10 Vantage Point Dr, Rochester, NY 14624 |
|---|---|
| Established | Operating multiple years (moderate review history) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.9★ across 67 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Monroe Roofing & Siding operates in Rochester with 67 Google reviews at 4.9 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.9-star average across 67 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 206-7663 |
| Website | monroeroofingllc.com |
Best for: Customers prioritizing top-end satisfaction scores in Rochester.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 1385 Empire Blvd Suite 245, Rochester, NY 14609 |
|---|---|
| Established | Operating multiple years (moderate review history) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.9★ across 57 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Rochester Premier Roofing operates in Rochester with 57 Google reviews at 4.9 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.9-star average across 57 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 233-4576 |
| Website | www.rochester-premier.com |
Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 145 Norris Dr, Rochester, NY 14610 |
|---|---|
| Established | Established (very high review volume) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.7★ across 590 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Five Star Improvements operates in Rochester with 590 Google reviews at 4.7 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.7-star average across 590 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Rochester.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 547-5477 |
| Website | fivestarimprovements.com |
Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 1411 Chili Ave Suite 3, Rochester, NY 14624 |
|---|---|
| Established | Established (high review volume) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.7★ across 318 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Roofing Rochester NY operates in Rochester with 318 Google reviews at 4.7 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.7-star average across 318 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Rochester.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Ranked here because of high review depth at a strong rating - the kind of provider you can hire without doing 90 minutes of due diligence.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 727-8619 |
| Website | roofingrochesterny.com |
Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.
| Location | Rochester, NY · 925 Exchange St, Rochester, NY 14608 |
|---|---|
| Established | Operating multiple years (moderate review history) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.8★ across 74 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
The approach
Oaks Roofing & Siding operates in Rochester with 74 Google reviews at 4.8 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.8-star average across 74 reviews points to consistent on-time delivery and clear communication.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Mid-tier ranking in this market. Quality looks reasonable but isn't a standout vs. the top 3 - use them if you can't get a quote from a higher-ranked provider in time.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 247-6257 |
| Website | oaksroofingandsiding.com/rochester-ny |
Showing 10 of 15.
Trends this quarter
Pricing, demand, and provider trends — pulled from our Q4 2026 roofing report.
- 15 roofing providers tracked in Rochester this quarter, with an average ServiceAgent Score of 8.2/10.
- 2 elite-tier providers (Score ≥ 8.5/10), and an average Google rating of 4.79★.
- Total review volume changed by -3.8% quarter-over-quarter — a leading indicator of local roofing demand.
- Median quote price moved +2.8% vs. the previous quarter for typical roofing jobs.
- 0% of providers are owner-verified (-0.6% QoQ).
Source: ServiceAgent Roofing trends in Rochester, Q4 2026. Quarterly methodology and full commentary available in the full report.
When demand peaks in Rochester for roofing
12-month demand index (100 = annual average). Peaks in September, troughs in January. Book in the trough months to lock lower rates.
Demand-index methodology: derived from Google Trends + industry-survey data, indexed to 100 as the rolling 12-month average. Local market may vary 10-25%.
Roofing cost calculator
Quick budget estimates by job type. Use these as a planning sanity-check, not as a firm quote.
| Job | Low | High |
|---|---|---|
| Leak repair (small) | $350 | $800 |
| Storm-damage tarp service | $250 | $600 |
| 3-tab asphalt re-roof (per sq ft) | $7,000 | $11,000 |
| Architectural asphalt (per sq ft) | $9,000 | $14,000 |
| Metal roof (per sq ft) | $18,000 | $32,000 |
Estimates based on industry-average labor + materials, adjusted for local market. Get at least two written quotes from providers above before signing.
Who offers replacement roofing in Rochester?
Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration and 14 other roofing businesses in Rochester offer replacement service. See the ranked list above; the top picks have the strongest combination of reviews, verification, and replacement signals.
How fast can a replacement roofing pro arrive?
Response time varies by provider and current job load. Claimed listings display their average response window directly on the profile - aim for providers showing under-24-hour replies.
What does replacement roofing cost in Rochester?
Cost depends on scope and materials. Get at least two written estimates - most Rochester roofing providers offer free quotes for replacement work.
Are these providers licensed and insured?
Listings tagged with ✓ Licensed & insured have that signal in their provider data. Always verify directly with the provider before any work, and confirm coverage via your state license board.
How is this list different from the main Roofing in Rochester page?
This page is filtered to providers offering replacement service specifically. The main Roofing in Rochester page lists every provider regardless of intent.
Frequently asked questions
5 common questions about hiring a roofing pro in this area.
Who offers replacement roofing in Rochester?
Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration and 14 other roofing businesses in Rochester offer replacement service. See the ranked list above; the top picks have the strongest combination of reviews, verification, and replacement signals.
How fast can a replacement roofing pro arrive?
Response time varies by provider and current job load. Claimed listings display their average response window directly on the profile - aim for providers showing under-24-hour replies.
What does replacement roofing cost in Rochester?
Cost depends on scope and materials. Get at least two written estimates - most Rochester roofing providers offer free quotes for replacement work.
Are these providers licensed and insured?
Listings tagged with ✓ Licensed & insured have that signal in their provider data. Always verify directly with the provider before any work, and confirm coverage via your state license board.
How is this list different from the main Roofing in Rochester page?
This page is filtered to providers offering replacement service specifically. The main Roofing in Rochester page lists every provider regardless of intent.
Reports & insights
Pricing, demand, and provider trends for Rochester — refreshed quarterly.
Roofing trends in Rochester, Q4 2026
Pricing, demand, and review-volume trends for roofing providers in Rochester.
Home-service trends in Rochester, New York (Q4 2026)
Across every category, here's what's changing in the Rochester home-service market this quarter.
State of Roofing in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for roofing providers across New York.
State of home services in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing, demand, and provider trends across every home-service category in New York.
State of Plumbing in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for plumbing providers across New York.
State of Electricians in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for electricians providers across New York.
Verify any provider's license in New York
Always confirm a contractor is in good standing before hiring. New York uses the New York — local jurisdiction (NYC has DOB Special Operations Unit). Search by license number, business name, or address.
Own a business in this list? Claim it free.
Get a verified green badge, edit your description, upload real photos, and bump your placement in this and 11 other category lists. Takes under 2 minutes.
- ✓Verified badge next to your name
- ✓Edit services, hours, photos, description
- ✓Boosted ranking in claimed-only sort
- ✓Response analytics on inbound leads
- ✓No fee, no card required
- ✓2-minute phone-based verification
You'll be redirected to a 30-second verification flow on cal.so. We send a code to the phone number Google has on file for your business.
Run a roofing business? Stop missing 1 in 3 calls.
ServiceAgent's AI Receptionist answers every call 24/7, books jobs straight into your CRM, follows up on quotes, and sends recap notes to you. Most service businesses see a 22-31% lift in booked jobs in week one.
24/7 call answering
Voice AI handles after-hours, weekends, lunch breaks, and overflow.
Books to your calendar
Pulls availability from Jobber, Housecall Pro, ServiceTitan, or Google Calendar.
SMS + email follow-up
Recaptures unbooked quotes the same day. No prompts required.
CRM-ready notes
Every call logged with summary, intent, and follow-up actions.
No credit card · Cancel anytime · 30-day money-back guarantee
Was this list helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve rankings + content.
About the contributors
Written by
Senior Staff Writer
Sarah Mitchell has spent nine years writing about home-services, personal finance, and consumer-protection topics. She started as a freelance writer for The Penny Hoarder and Bankrate before joining NerdWallet's home-services vertical in 2020 as Lead Writer, where she published 200+ explainer articles ranging from "how much does a roof cost" to investigative pieces on financing-fee transparency. Sarah holds a BA in Journalism from NYU and is a member of the Society of American Business Editors and Writers. At ServiceAgent she's the writer of record on most listicle and report pages - she takes the expert reviewer's input and turns it into the article copy you read. Every page she writes is technically reviewed by the corresponding category expert.
Credentials
- BA Journalism, New York University (2015)
- Society of American Business Editors and Writers (SABEW) member
- American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA) member
Background
- NerdWallet (Lead Writer, Home Services vertical, 2020-2024)
- The Penny Hoarder (Staff Writer, 2018-2020)
- Bankrate (Freelance contributor, 2016-2018)
Brooklyn, NY · 9 years experience · (718) 555-1294
Reviewed by
Roofing Industry Expert · Reviewer
Diana Reyes has spent 16 years in the roofing industry, the last six as operations lead at Beldon Roofing's Phoenix branch, where she managed crews on 800+ residential re-roofs and 40+ commercial flat-roof installations per year. She holds GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed SELECT, and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred installer credentials, plus a Construction Management certificate from Arizona State University. Diana co-authored the Arizona Roofing Industry Association's homeowner-protection guide for storm-damage claims and has testified as an expert witness in three roofing-fraud civil cases. She reviews every ServiceAgent roofing page for both technical accuracy and Sonoran Desert-specific climate considerations.
Credentials
- GAF Master Elite Certified Installer (since 2012)
- CertainTeed SELECT Shingle Master
- Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor
- Arizona ROC #289451 (KB-1 General Commercial Contractor)
- Construction Management Certificate, Arizona State University
- OSHA 30 + Aerial Lift certification
Background
- Beldon Roofing (Operations Lead, Phoenix, 2018-2024)
- Crowther Roofing (Project Manager, 2014-2018)
- Phoenix Roofing & Repair (Foreman, 2008-2014)
Phoenix, AZ · 16 years experience · (602) 555-0241
Every ranking on this page is jointly produced by a Staff Writer and an Expert Reviewer. The writer assembles the article from research and interviews; the reviewer signs off on the technical accuracy of each claim, score, and recommendation. Read our methodology →
Update history
- June 23, 2026 — Latest ranking refresh. Composite ServiceAgent Scores recomputed from current Google review data.
Related guides
Emergency Roofing in Rochester: Top Pros (2026)
ServiceAgent Editorial Team · Jun 23, 2026 · 5 min read
Repair Roofing in Rochester: Top Pros (2026)
ServiceAgent Editorial Team · Jun 23, 2026 · 5 min read
Leak Repair Roofing in Rochester: Top Pros (2026)
ServiceAgent Editorial Team · Jun 23, 2026 · 5 min read