Published May 12, 2026 · Last updated October 21, 2026
Replacement Roofing in Penfield, New York: Top Pro (2027)
Quick answer
The top-ranked Roofing provider in Penfield is Roof Rangers (Penfield), with a 4.7★ rating across 212 Google reviews and a ServiceAgent Score of 8.2/10.
TL;DR
- 1 replacement roofing provider match in Penfield, New York.
- Top pick: Roof Rangers (ServiceAgent Score 8.2/10).
- Median ServiceAgent Score: 8.2/10.
- 0 owner-verified listings.
- Filtered for Replacement: full tear-off + new roof.
At-a-glance: top 1 roofing pros in Penfield
Compare the top picks side-by-side. Full reviews of each below.
| # | Provider | SA Score |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | Roof Rangers | 8.2 |
SA Score = ServiceAgent composite (0–10). Tap a row number to jump to the full review.
How we chose these
Same scoring engine as the main Penfield roofing ranking, with an additional filter step: we look for Replacement signals in each provider's business categories, service tags, and recent review text.
When the Replacement filter would surface fewer than five providers, we fall back to showing top-rated roofing pros generally - they are far more likely to handle replacement work than an unrated provider would be.
Full formula on the methodology page.
1 Best Roofing Companies Ranked
Ranked by composite ServiceAgent Score. 1 verified businesses match.
1. Roof Rangers
Best for: Mid-tier roofing jobs where price and quality both matter.
| Location | Penfield, NY · 3410 Atlantic Ave, Penfield, NY 14526 |
|---|---|
| Established | Established (high review volume) |
| Specialization | Roofing |
| Rating | 4.7★ across 212 Google reviews |
| Status | Unclaimed listing (Google data) |
| Source | Public Google Business Profile · data as of May 12, 2026 |
The approach
Roof Rangers operates in Penfield with 212 Google reviews at 4.7 stars - a steady mid-tier signal in our composite scoring.
- Maintains an active website with service detail.
- Direct phone published - no lead form gatekeeping.
- Active on Google with up-to-date contact info.
✓ Strong review signal
4.7-star average across 212 reviews puts them in the upper tier for roofing providers in Penfield.
⚠ Watch out for
After-hours and emergency response isn't signaled on the public profile - confirm availability directly if your job is time-sensitive.
Our take
Our top pick in Penfield. The 8.2/10 composite comes from a rare combination of review depth (212 reviews), a 4.7-star rating, and complete profile data.
| 24/7 emergency | Not advertised |
|---|---|
| Free estimate | Not advertised |
| Licensed + insured | Not advertised - verify before hiring |
| Phone | (585) 632-1702 |
| Website | theroofrangers.com/the-roof-rangers-your-local-roofing-experts |
How to choose a roofing pro
The ranking does the research; these five checks help you turn the shortlist into the right hire.
- 1
Start with the top of the ranking, not an ad
The providers ranked highest in Penfield earned it on review depth, rating, and data completeness — not on ad spend. Shortlist two or three from the top before you start calling.
- 2
Get two or three quotes in writing
Pricing for roofing work varies by scope and local market. Written quotes from a few shortlisted pros let you compare apples to apples and spot an outlier before you commit.
- 3
Read the most recent reviews, not just the average
A strong average can hide a recent slide in quality. Sort reviews by newest and look for how the business handles problems — a thoughtful reply to a bad review often tells you more than the star count.
- 4
Confirm licensing, insurance, and scope before work starts
Ask for the license number and proof of insurance, and get the full scope of work plus any parts/labor warranty in writing before any roofing job begins. Verify the license on your state board if the work is significant.
- 5
Match the provider to your actual job
A high-volume operator is great for a routine job; a smaller specialist may be a better fit for an unusual one. Use the scorecard above to pick for your situation, not just the overall rank.
Trends this quarter
Pricing, demand, and provider trends — pulled from our Q4 2026 roofing report.
- 178 roofing providers tracked in New York this quarter, with an average ServiceAgent Score of 7.9/10.
- 12 elite-tier providers (Score ≥ 8.5/10), and an average Google rating of 4.82★.
- Total review volume changed by +10.9% quarter-over-quarter — a leading indicator of local roofing demand.
- Median quote price moved -5.9% vs. the previous quarter for typical roofing jobs.
- 0% of providers are owner-verified (+3.8% QoQ).
Source: ServiceAgent State of Roofing in New York, Q4 2026. Quarterly methodology and full commentary available in the full report.
When demand peaks in Penfield for roofing
12-month demand index (100 = annual average). Peaks in September, troughs in January. Book in the trough months to lock lower rates.
Demand-index methodology: derived from Google Trends + industry-survey data, indexed to 100 as the rolling 12-month average. Local market may vary 10-25%.
Pricing: what roofing costs
Quick budget estimates by job type. Use these as a planning sanity-check, not as a firm quote.
| Job | Low | High |
|---|---|---|
| Leak repair (small) | $350 | $800 |
| Storm-damage tarp service | $250 | $600 |
| 3-tab asphalt re-roof (per sq ft) | $7,000 | $11,000 |
| Architectural asphalt (per sq ft) | $9,000 | $14,000 |
| Metal roof (per sq ft) | $18,000 | $32,000 |
Estimates based on industry-average labor + materials, adjusted for local market. Get at least two written quotes from providers above before signing.
What to know about hiring Roofing
Roofing is a high-stakes, weather-dependent job where material choice and install quality matter more than the headline quote.
What drives the price
Roof size (squares), pitch, material (asphalt vs. metal vs. tile), tear-off of the old roof, and decking repairs found mid-job.
What to check
Manufacturer certifications, a written workmanship warranty, proof of insurance, and that they'll pull the permit.
When to call
After storm season for inspections; get multiple quotes and avoid storm-chasers who knock door-to-door after hail.
Why trust this list
This page narrows the full Penfield roofing directory to providers that explicitly serve replacement requests. We surfaced them by scanning provider categories, service tags, and review text for relevant signals.
If you're looking at this page, you probably need replacement roofing now - so we've ordered the list by composite ServiceAgent Score and surfaced the response-time indicator on every card. Call the top three; the first to pick up usually wins the job.
Frequently asked questions
8 common questions about hiring a roofing pro in this area.
Who offers replacement roofing in Penfield?
Roof Rangers and 0 other roofing businesses in Penfield offer replacement service. See the ranked list above; the top picks have the strongest combination of reviews, verification, and replacement signals.
How fast can a replacement roofing pro arrive?
Response time varies by provider and current job load. Claimed listings display their average response window directly on the profile - aim for providers showing under-24-hour replies.
What does replacement roofing cost in Penfield?
Cost depends on scope and materials. Get at least two written estimates - most Penfield roofing providers offer free quotes for replacement work.
Are these providers licensed and insured?
Listings tagged with ✓ Licensed & insured have that signal in their provider data. Always verify directly with the provider before any work, and confirm coverage via your state license board.
How is this list different from the main Roofing in Penfield page?
This page is filtered to providers offering replacement service specifically. The main Roofing in Penfield page lists every provider regardless of intent.
Who are the highest-rated roofing providers in Penfield?
Based on composite ServiceAgent Score, Roof Rangers in Penfield ranks #1 (8.2/10).
How does the ServiceAgent Score work?
It's a 0-10 composite of a Trust Score (40% - data quality, verification and review-volume credibility) and a Recommendation Score (60% - the Google rating Bayesian-shrunk toward the category mean using a 25-review prior). Full formula on the methodology page.
Are these listings verified?
Every listing is pulled from active Google Business Profile data. 0 of these 1 listings are currently ServiceAgent-verified (owners completed our claim flow). Verified listings get a green badge in the ranking.
Reports & insights
Pricing, demand, and provider trends for Penfield — refreshed quarterly.
State of Roofing in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for roofing providers across New York.
State of home services in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing, demand, and provider trends across every home-service category in New York.
State of Plumbing in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for plumbing providers across New York.
State of Electricians in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for electricians providers across New York.
State of Landscaping in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for landscaping providers across New York.
State of HVAC in New York, Q4 2026
Pricing trends, demand signals, and elite-tier shifts for hvac providers across New York.
Verify any provider's license in New York
Always confirm a contractor is in good standing before hiring. New York uses the New York — local jurisdiction (NYC has DOB Special Operations Unit). Search by license number, business name, or address.
Own a business in this list? Claim it free.
Get a verified green badge, edit your description, upload real photos, and bump your placement in this and 11 other category lists. Takes under 2 minutes.
- ✓Verified badge next to your name
- ✓Edit services, hours, photos, description
- ✓Boosted ranking in claimed-only sort
- ✓Response analytics on inbound leads
- ✓No fee, no card required
- ✓2-minute phone-based verification
Fill out the verification form right here. We'll match it to your Google Business Profile and confirm by phone within one business day.
Run a roofing business? Stop missing 1 in 3 calls.
ServiceAgent's AI Receptionist answers every call 24/7, books jobs straight into your CRM, follows up on quotes, and sends recap notes to you, so you stop losing jobs to missed calls.
24/7 call answering
Voice AI handles after-hours, weekends, lunch breaks, and overflow.
Books to your calendar
Pulls availability from Jobber, Housecall Pro, ServiceTitan, or Google Calendar.
SMS + email follow-up
Recaptures unbooked quotes the same day. No prompts required.
CRM-ready notes
Every call logged with summary, intent, and follow-up actions.
No credit card · Cancel anytime · 30-day money-back guarantee
Was this list helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve rankings + content.
About the author
Written by
Growth & Product Marketing, ServiceAgent
Shaambhav Shankar works in product marketing at SaaS Labs, the company behind ServiceAgent, and describes himself as a marketing generalist with six years of experience in SaaS. He studied at Symbiosis International University and is based in the Greater Delhi Area. He writes the bulk of the ServiceAgent blog, covering call answering, CRM and the operational side of running a home services business, and authors and maintains the ServiceAgent Directory rankings.
Credentials
- Symbiosis International University (2016-2019)
- Digital Marketing, Google India (2020)
- Financial Modelling and Valuation, Ernst & Young (2019)
- Building with the Claude API, Anthropic (2026)
- AI Fluency for Builders, Anthropic (2026)
- Introduction to Model Context Protocol, Anthropic (2026)
Greater Delhi Area, India · 6 years experience
Every ranking on this page is written and maintained by Shaambhav Shankar, who owns the ranking methodology and verifies each provider listing against public data. No pay-to-rank, no sponsored placements. Read our methodology →
Update history
- October 21, 2026 — Latest ranking refresh. Composite ServiceAgent Scores recomputed from current Google review data.
Related guides
Emergency Roofing in Penfield: Top Pros (2027)
ServiceAgent Editorial Team · Oct 21, 2026 · 5 min read
Repair Roofing in Penfield: Top Pros (2027)
ServiceAgent Editorial Team · Oct 21, 2026 · 5 min read
Leak Repair Roofing in Penfield: Top Pros (2027)
ServiceAgent Editorial Team · Oct 21, 2026 · 5 min read