Lesson 3 of 7 · 8 min

Reading the Google Business Profile, reviews and website booking

Check the Google Business Profile, the reviews and the website booking for leaks.

Read the lesson

Goal: Read a business's public profile, reviews and website for leaks, and record a dated baseline.

You need: Lessons 1 and 2. A phone and a laptop.

Why this matters

Most customers meet a business online before they call. They search, read the profile, scan the reviews and tap a button. Each step is a chance to lose them.

The numbers are large. 97% of consumers read reviews for local businesses. 89% expect the owner to respond to reviews. 80% of homeowners factor in online booking when they choose a pro. A business with old reviews, wrong hours or no way to book online loses customers it never hears from.

Fig 1Sourced figures

Customers check online before they call

97%Consumers who read reviews for local businesses
89%Expect the owner to respond to reviews
80%Homeowners who factor in online booking
A business with old reviews or no booking loses customers it never hears from.

This part of the audit takes about 20 minutes. It finds leaks in Catch and Keep that a call test cannot see. It also gives you a baseline. In three months, you show the owner what moved.

Part 1: the Google Business Profile

Search for the business by name on your phone, as a customer would. Open its profile. Check six things:

  1. Phone number. Does it match the number on the website and the trucks? A wrong or old number sends calls nowhere.
  2. Hours. Are they right for every day, including weekends and holidays? Wrong hours turn callers away.
  3. Categories and services. Do they match the work the business wants? A plumber listed only as "plumber" may miss "water heater installation" searches.
  4. Booking or website button. Is there one, and does it work on a phone?
  5. Photos. Are there recent photos of real work, trucks and the team?
  6. Questions and answers. Are customer questions answered, or left open?

Then check the same phone and hours on Yelp and Facebook. Listings that disagree confuse customers and search engines.

Part 2: the reviews

Reviews are both a sales tool and a mirror. Record five numbers with today's date:

  1. Review count on Google.
  2. Average rating.
  3. Date of the newest review. If it is months old, nobody is asking.
  4. Reviews in the last 90 days. This shows the current pace.
  5. Owner replies. Count how many of the last 20 reviews have a reply.

Then read the last 10 low reviews, 1 to 3 stars. Place each complaint in a Job Loop stage. "Nobody called me back" is Catch. "The tech was two hours late" is Book. "They never sent the quote" is Collect. Patterns tell you where the business hurts.

Do not judge the business by the rating alone. A 4.8 with 20 old reviews is weaker than a 4.6 with 150 recent ones.

Fig 2

Rating alone does not tell you much

4.8 stars, 20 old reviews
  • Newest review months old
  • Nobody is asking
  • Little for customers or AI assistants to read
4.6 stars, 150 recent reviews
  • New reviews every month
  • Customers see current work
  • More for search and AI assistants to read
Recent reviews and many of them beat a high rating nobody adds to.

Part 3: the website

Open the website on a phone, not a laptop. Most homeowners search on a phone. Check:

  1. Click to call. Can you tap the phone number to call?
  2. Booking. Can you book a time online, or only send a form?
  3. The form. How many fields does it have? Long forms lose people.
  4. Chat. Is there a chat box? Who answers it at night?
  5. Speed of reply. You tested this in lesson 2. Note the minutes to first reply.

A form is not booking. A customer who fills in a form at 9 pm still waits for a call. A booking page lets them pick a time right away.

Fig 3

A form is not booking

Web form
  • Customer sends a form at 9 pm
  • Waits for a call next day
  • May book another pro first
Booking page
  • Customer opens the page at 9 pm
  • Picks an open time
  • Job is on the calendar tonight
A booking page lets the customer pick a time at once. A form makes them wait.

Reviews now feed AI answers too

Customers do not only read reviews themselves. AI assistants now read them when someone asks for a local recommendation. An assistant can only recommend what it can read. Recent reviews, owner replies and correct listings give it more to work with.

This changes how you explain reviews to an owner. A review is no longer just social proof for one reader. It is data that search engines and AI assistants use to decide who to show. A business with steady new reviews and correct hours everywhere is easier to recommend.

Do not promise a ranking or an AI recommendation. Nobody controls those. Say only that recent reviews and correct listings help, and that the business can control both.

Sort the findings

By now you may have 10 or more findings. The owner cannot act on 10 things. Sort them into three groups:

  1. Losing customers today. A wrong phone number, wrong hours, a full voicemail box, a form nobody answers. These go first.
  2. Losing customers slowly. Few new reviews, no owner replies, no online booking. These are real, but they take weeks to show.
  3. Nice to fix. Old photos, a missing category, an unanswered question. Note them, but do not lead with them.
Fig 4

Sort the findings before the report

Customers lost now
Plan itFew new reviews, no online booking
Do firstWrong phone or hours, full voicemail, unanswered form
Leave for laterLow loss, slow to fix
Nice to fixOld photos, a missing category
Fast to fix
Lead with what loses customers today and is fast to fix.

Then match each finding in the first two groups to a Job Loop stage and a ServiceAgent tool. Write the tool next to the finding, so the report is ready to use. A slow form reply is Catch: the speed-to-lead workflow fixes it. No new reviews is Keep: automatic review requests fix it. No online booking is Book: the booking page fixes it.

Some fixes need no software at all, and they still count. Correct hours on Yelp take five minutes. Point one of these out during the audit, so the owner can fix it the same day. It shows them you help first and sell second. Owners remember the person who found the full voicemail box. They also tell other owners about it.

Size changes what you read

For an owner-operator, there is usually one profile and one website. Read them in full.

For a fleet, check whether there are duplicate profiles. Search the business name and the main phone number separately. Old addresses and old phone numbers often leave a second profile behind.

For a multi-location brand, read the profile for each location. Compare ratings, hours and reply rates. One weak location can hurt the whole brand.

Build it in ServiceAgent

You record the baseline now and compare it after go-live, when the client uses ServiceAgent.

  1. Write the dated baseline in the prospect's contact note in your own account.
  2. After go-live, find the review requests page with Search or run a command.... The Reviews inbox collects reviews from Google, Yelp, Facebook, Trustpilot, Angi and HomeAdvisor.
  3. Open Settings → Service Catalog → Review requests & settings. Here you later set requests to go after each job.
  4. Listings connect through Connect Platform: Google Business Profile, Yelp, Facebook and Trustpilot.
  5. Check it works: after 90 days, count reviews in the last 90 days again. Compare with the baseline.

Worked example: Northside Plumbing

Here is what you found for Northside Plumbing before Carol signed:

  • Google rating 4.6, with 112 reviews.
  • The newest review was 5 weeks old. Only 4 reviews came in the last 90 days.
  • Carol had replied to 3 of the last 20 reviews.
  • Google showed Saturday hours of 9 am to 1 pm. Yelp said closed on Saturday.
  • Of 10 low reviews, 6 said nobody called back or answered. That is Catch. Two were Book, one Collect and one Keep.
  • The website had click to call and a 9-field form. There was no online booking and no chat.
  • Your form test on Tuesday at 2 pm got a reply on Wednesday at 4 pm, 26 hours later.
Fig 5Example numbers

Northside Plumbing's dated online baseline

4.6Google rating, 112 reviews
4Reviews in the last 90 days
3 of 20Recent reviews with an owner reply
26 hoursReply to the web form
A baseline with a date lets you prove change in 90 days.

Each finding supports the call test. The Catch leak shows up three ways: missed calls, slow form replies and complaints in reviews. That consistency makes your report hard to argue with. Write the date on every number, so the 90-day check compares like with like.

Fig 6Example numbers

Northside's 10 low reviews by stage

Catch6
Book2
Collect1
Keep1
The reviews point to the same Catch leak as the test calls.

Common mistakes

  • Checking on a laptop only. Customers use phones. Test on a phone.
  • Judging by the rating alone. Count recent reviews and replies too.
  • Forgetting the date. A baseline without a date cannot prove change.
  • Skipping other listings. Wrong hours on Yelp lose customers too.

Do this now

Run all three parts on the business you tested in lesson 2. Write the dated baseline in one note. Place each low-review complaint in a Job Loop stage.

Practice the conversation

  1. Operator Carol, I read your Google profile and your last 20 reviews.
  2. Owner We're at 4.6. That's good, right?
  3. Operator It's a good rating. But only 4 new reviews came in the last three months.
  4. Owner People just don't leave them.
  5. Operator Most will if you ask right after the job. Right now, nobody asks.
  6. Owner What else?
  7. Operator Six of your low reviews say nobody called back. That matches the test calls.
  8. Owner Huh. I never read them that way.
  9. Operator And Yelp says you're closed on Saturday. Google says open.
  10. Owner That's an easy fix.

Quick check

  1. You take on a new client. The owner wants review requests on today. You have not looked at the public profile. What do you do first?
    • Turn on requests now and check the profile next month
    • Record the review count, rating, newest review date and replies, with today's date
    • Fix the Yelp hours first
    • Ask an AI assistant to recommend a business in the trade
  2. Which website finding is a Catch leak?
    • The logo is old
    • The form reply took 26 hours
    • The site has no blog
    • The photos are from last year
  3. Business A has a 4.9 rating with 25 reviews, the newest from 2 years ago. Business B has 4.6 with 140 reviews, 15 in the last 90 days. Which has the stronger review profile today?
    • Business A, because its rating is higher
    • Business B, because its reviews are recent and many
    • They are equal
    • Neither, because ratings do not matter

ServiceAgent UniversityLearn to run a service business on autopilot. Free courses, Blueprints and certification for Service Operators.

Learn

Get certified

Community