Lesson 4 of 6 · 7 min

Review inbox, AI reply drafts and Auto-Reply on Growth

Reply to every review with AI drafts, or with Auto-Reply on the Growth plan.

Read the lesson

Goal: Reply to every review from one inbox, in the owner's voice. Use AI on Growth and reply by hand on Core.

You need: Core for the inbox and requests. Growth or above for AI Review Auto-Reply. Screens: Reviews inbox, Workflows, Business identity & branding.

Why this matters

BrightLocal reports 89% of consumers expect owners to respond to reviews. Every unanswered review tells the next reader that nobody is listening. Every reply, good or bad, shows a real person runs the business.

Owners know this, but replying takes time. Reviews arrive on several sites. Each needs a login. A reply to a bad review needs care. So replies pile up, then stop.

ServiceAgent brings the main review sites into one inbox. On Growth, the AI drafts and posts replies in the brand voice. On Core, the owner or you reply from the same inbox by hand.

Fig 1

Replies on Core vs Growth

Core
  • Reviews inbox: yes
  • AI Review Auto-Reply: no
  • Owner or Operator replies by hand
  • Cost per reply: staff time
Growth
  • Reviews inbox: yes
  • AI Review Auto-Reply: yes
  • AI replies; owner writes low-star replies
  • Cost per reply: 1 credit
Both plans get the inbox. Growth moves most reply time from the owner to the AI.

The idea: one inbox, one voice, one rule for bad reviews

One inbox. Reviews inbox collects reviews from Google, Yelp, Facebook, Trustpilot, Angi and HomeAdvisor. Use Filters for Source, Status and Rating. Use Sync to pull new reviews.

Fig 2

One inbox for every review site

Reviews inbox

SourceGoogle, Yelp, Facebook, Trustpilot, Angi, HomeAdvisor
StatusFind the reviews with no reply yet
Rating1 to 5 stars
Sync
Filter by source, status and rating. Sync pulls in the newest reviews.

One voice. AI replies follow the brand voice set in Settings → Brand & Locations → Business identity & branding. If replies sound stiff, fix the voice once at the source. Do not edit every reply by hand.

One rule for bad reviews. Auto-Reply skips reviews that need a human response. It lists them on the Dashboard: "N reviews need a human response", with a link to the reviews page. The app decides which reviews those are. So also agree a rule with the owner: 1 and 2 star reviews get a personal reply from the owner. The AI handles the rest. Did a low-star review get an AI reply anyway? The owner reads it the same day and rewrites it in their own words.

Fig 3

A review from site to reply

  1. Review posted on a connected site
  2. Lands in Reviews inboxSync pulls it in
  3. Is it 1 or 2 stars?YesOwner alert and task; owner replies the same dayNoAI reply in the brand voice (Growth), or by hand (Core)
  4. Every review gets a reply
The AI handles most replies. The owner handles the hard ones the same day.

A good reply is short. It thanks the customer by first name, names the job, and adds one human line. For a bad review, it apologizes, gives no excuses, and offers a direct phone number.

ReviewReply pattern
5 starsThanks, names the job, one warm line
3 to 4 starsThanks, notes the issue, says what changed
1 to 2 starsOwner replies: sorry, no excuses, direct number

Sample replies

Show the owner these patterns before you switch anything on. They set the tone for the AI and for them.

5 stars: "Thanks, Maria. Glad the new furnace is keeping the house warm. We appreciate you choosing Cedar HVAC."

3 stars: "Thanks for the honest review, Tom. You are right that we arrived late. We have added time between jobs so it does not happen again."

1 star, written by the owner: "Tom, I'm sorry. This is not the service we want you to get. Please call me directly at [number], and I will make it right."

A reply never argues facts in public. It never shares the customer's private details. It never offers money in exchange for changing a review.

How often to read

The inbox is not set-and-forget, even with AI. Use this rhythm:

  • First month: read every posted reply each week.
  • After that: read a sample every two weeks.
  • Always: the owner gets an alert for each 1 or 2 star review on the same day.
Fig 4

How often to read the replies

  1. Week 1Read the first 10 AI replies before you trust it
  2. Weeks 1 to 4Read every posted reply each week
  3. Month 2 onRead a sample every two weeks
  4. Any dayA 1 or 2 star review alerts the owner the same day
Even with AI, someone reads. Trust grows with each clean week.

Build it in ServiceAgent

  1. Connect the review sources. Check that each site the business uses shows in Reviews inbox. Click Sync to pull the latest reviews.
  2. Set the brand voice. Open Settings → Brand & Locations → Business identity & branding. Write the voice in plain words: "Friendly, plain, short. Uses first names. Signs off with 'Carol and the Northside team'."
  3. On Growth, turn on AI Review Auto-Reply. Find the switch in the client's account. Then read the first 10 replies before you trust it. Each day, check the Dashboard for reviews that need a human response.
  4. Alert on bad reviews. Build a workflow that alerts the owner on negative reviews. Start from a sentiment template that reacts to negative reviews. Add Send Notification and Create CRM Task for the owner.
  5. On Core, reply by hand. Set a twice-weekly task to open Reviews inbox, filter Status for unreplied, and reply. The workflow steps Generate Review Reply and Publish Review Reply exist. Check if they help draft on Core in this account.
  6. Read replies weekly. Each week, read the posted replies. If they drift from the owner's voice, fix the voice setting.
  7. Check it works. Leave a test review where you can, or wait for the next real one. Check it shows in the inbox, gets a reply in the right voice, and posts on the site.

Worked example: Cedar HVAC

Cedar HVAC has 9 techs and runs on Growth. Assume an example of 30 new reviews a month.

  • Owner's own replies: assume 2 low-star reviews a month. They write those themselves, about 10 minutes each.
  • AI review replies: the other 28 × 1 credit = 28 credits a month.
  • Time saved: if each reply took the owner 4 minutes, that is 28 × 4 = 112 minutes a month.
Fig 5Example numbers

Cedar HVAC review replies a month

New reviews a month30
−Low-star reviews the owner writes themselves2
×1 credit per AI reply1
AI review replies (28)28 credits
Each AI review reply costs 1 credit. The owner's own replies cost their time, not credits.

The owner reads the posted replies after week one. They say they sound stiff and formal. You do not edit each one. You change the voice in Business identity & branding to "plain, warm, short, first names". You check the next 10 replies in your weekly read.

Fig 6Example numbers

Fixing a stiff voice at the source

Voice not set
  • Reply: "Thank you for your valued feedback."
  • Reads stiff and formal
  • Owner wants to edit each one
Voice: plain, warm, short, first names
  • Reply: "Thanks, Maria. Glad the new furnace is keeping the house warm."
  • Sounds like the owner
  • No hand edits
Change the voice once in Business identity & branding. Every reply after that changes.

Replies also help the next customer decide. A reader who sees the owner fix a problem in public often trusts the business more.

Track the reply rate each month, the same way as the Lesson 1 baseline. Summit Roofing started at 45%. The goal is 100% on every site in the inbox.

On Core, the same 30 reviews take the owner or you about 2 hours a month by hand. That time is one reason to move a busy client to Growth.

Common mistakes

  • Editing every stiff reply by hand. Fix: change the brand voice once, then check the next replies.
  • Letting AI answer 1-star reviews alone. Fix: the owner replies to low-star reviews themselves.
  • Promising Auto-Reply on Core. Fix: AI Review Auto-Reply needs Growth or above.
  • No weekly read. Fix: read posted replies every week for the first month, then every two weeks.

Do this now

Write a brand voice paragraph for one client, in under 50 words. Then write three sample replies by hand: a 5-star, a 3-star and a 1-star. Use them to check the AI's first replies.

Practice the conversation

  1. Operator You have 20 reviews with no reply. Do you know which sites they are on?
  2. Owner Google mostly. Some on Yelp. I don't log into Yelp.
  3. Operator ServiceAgent pulls them into one inbox. On your plan, the AI can reply in your voice.
  4. Owner I don't want a robot answering my customers.
  5. Operator You set the voice. I read the first replies with you. And you answer every 1 or 2 star review yourself.
  6. Owner What does it cost?
  7. Operator One credit per reply. About 30 credits a month for you.
  8. Owner And if it sounds wrong?
  9. Operator We fix the voice once, and every reply after that changes.

Quick check

  1. A client on Growth has Auto-Reply on. The owner says the posted replies sound stiff and formal. What do you do?
    • Fix the brand voice setting once, then read the next replies
    • Edit each stiff reply by hand every week
    • Turn off Auto-Reply and move back to Core
    • Delete the stiff replies
  2. A Growth client gets 45 reviews a month. The owner writes the 3 low-star replies themselves. The AI replies to the rest. How many credits is that?
    • 3
    • 42
    • 45
    • 90
  3. A Core client asks for AI Review Auto-Reply. What do you tell them?
    • It is on every plan
    • It needs Growth or above; on Core, replies are by hand
    • It needs Franchise
    • Buy a credit pack to turn it on

ServiceAgent UniversityLearn to run a service business on autopilot. Free courses, Blueprints and certification for Service Operators.

Learn

Get certified

Community