The economics of maintenance plans
Learn why maintenance plans bring steady money in the slow months.
Read the lesson
Goal: Work out whether a maintenance plan makes money. Then explain the math to the owner in five minutes.
You need: The client's tune-up length, tech cost per hour and current customer count. No plan level is needed for the math.
Why this matters
Most home service revenue is lumpy. A hot July fills the board. A mild May leaves techs waiting for calls. A maintenance plan turns some of that lumpy work into booked visits the owner can plan around.
A plan also changes who the customer calls. A member already has the business's number, a visit on the calendar and a reason to stay. A one-time customer searches online the next time something breaks. That search is where the business loses the job to a competitor.
But a plan is not free money. Every member is a promise of future visits. If the price does not cover the tech hours, the owner pays to serve their own members. Your job is to show the real numbers before anyone signs up. Then the plan helps the business instead of draining it.
The numbers change with size:
| Business size | What the plan does | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Owner-operator (1 to 3 people) | Fills slow weeks with booked work | Too many visits in the same two months |
| Fleet (10 to 30 techs) | Keeps techs busy in shoulder seasons | Price too low across hundreds of members |
| Multi-location | Builds a steady base in each area | Different labor costs in each location |
The three numbers that decide the plan
Every plan has three parts. You need all three before you talk about price.
- Visit cost. Visits a year x hours a visit x tech cost per hour. Count drive time inside the hours.
- Card fees. Each payment costs 2.8% + 30¢ on a paid plan. Twelve small payments cost more than one large payment.
- Admin time. Someone books the visits, sends the renewals and answers questions. ServiceAgent automates most of it, but not all of it.
Revenue minus these three is what the owner keeps before parts and repairs.
The rule of thumb: the monthly price must cover the visit cost first. A plan priced below its visit cost loses money on every member, no matter how many join. For example, if two visits cost $150 a year, break-even is $12.50 a month. At $10 a month, each member brings $120 and loses $30. At $18, each brings $216 and keeps $66 before fees.
Where the monthly price must land
You do not set the price. The owner sets the price and the terms. You bring the cost math with their own numbers, so their price covers the visits.
Why members are worth more than the plan fee
The plan fee is only part of the value. Members tend to call the business they already pay. A tune-up visit also finds problems early. Those finds become repair work and, later, replacement quotes.
Do not put a number on this extra value unless the client's own records show it. Say it in words. "Members call you first, and tune-ups find repair work." Then show the plan math, which stands on its own.
Lead the pitch with priority service and visits that never get missed. A plan sold only as a discount gives members little reason to stay. The discount can be one perk among several.
Build it in ServiceAgent
The math is done outside the app, but the inputs come from it.
- Open
Contactsand filter byStatusandFilter by Tagsto count active customers. Note the total. - Open
Jobsand switch toListview. Filter byServicefor tune-ups over the last 12 months. Count them. - Open
Settings→Service Catalog→Services. Note the tune-up duration and price. - Ask the owner for the tech cost per hour. This is wage plus taxes and truck cost. Write down their number and the date.
- Open
Analytics→Appointments. NoteCompletion Rate. This shows how often booked visits really happen. - Put the numbers in a plan math sheet, like the one in the worked example. Use one row per input.
- Check it works: change one input, such as tech cost, by $5. The total should move by the amount you expect.
Inputs to collect before you talk price
- Active customer count
- Tune-ups done in the last 12 months
- Real tune-up time, drive included
- Tech cost per hour, from the owner
- Completion Rate for booked visits
Worked example: Polar Air Services
Polar Air Services has about 20 techs on Growth. The owner wants a plan with 2 tune-ups a year. These are example inputs for this lesson:
- Price: $18 a month ($216 a year)
- Members after year one: 300
- Tune-up time: 1.25 hours, drive included
- Tech cost: $60 an hour
Revenue: 300 members x $18 x 12 months = $64,800 a year.
Visit cost: 300 members x 2 visits = 600 visits. 600 visits x 1.25 hours x $60 = $45,000.
Left before fees: $64,800 − $45,000 = $19,800.
Plan math for Polar Air Services
Card fees if members pay monthly by payment link: Each $18 payment costs 2.8% x $18 + 30¢ = about 80.4¢. 3,600 payments x 80.4¢ = about $2,894 a year.
Card fees if members pay yearly: Each $216 payment costs 2.8% x $216 + 30¢ = about $6.35. 300 payments x $6.35 = about $1,905 a year.
Card fees a year: monthly vs yearly payments
Yearly billing saves Polar Air about $990 in card fees. It also means 300 payment links a year, not 3,600. With yearly billing, Polar keeps about $17,895 of the $64,800 before parts and admin.
Where Polar Air's plan revenue goes
- Visit cost$45,000
- Card fees, yearly billingabout $1,905
- Kept before parts and adminabout $17,895
Plan revenue$64,800
Break-even price: 2 visits x 1.25 hours x $60 = $150 a year per member. That is $12.50 a month before fees. Any price under that loses money.
Now the small case. Rivera Heating and Air has 2 people on Core. At the same price and cost, 80 members bring $17,280 a year and need 160 visits. Those visits must fit into the spring and fall shoulder weeks. Check the calendar before you say yes to 80 members.
Common mistakes
- Pricing from a competitor's flyer. Their labor cost is not your client's. Start from the client's own visit cost.
- Forgetting drive time. A 60-minute tune-up is often 90 minutes door to door. Use the real time the techs report.
- Selling the discount first. Members who joined for 15% off leave when they find a cheaper deal. Lead with priority service.
- Promising a renewal rate. No one knows how many members will renew. Track it after the first year instead.
- Ignoring capacity. 300 members want spring visits at the same time. Plan the visits across the season.
Do this now
Build a one-page plan math sheet for one real or practice client. Fill in the five inputs: members, price, visits a year, hours a visit and tech cost. Show revenue, visit cost, card fees both ways, and the break-even monthly price. Keep it to one page the owner can read in two minutes.
Practice the conversation
- Owner I want a plan. My buddy in Dayton charges $15 a month.
- Operator Good idea. Before we pick a price, can I show you what each member costs you?
- Owner Sure.
- Operator Two tune-ups at an hour and a quarter, at your $60 an hour. That is $150 a year per member.
- Owner So $15 a month barely covers it.
- Operator Right. $12.50 a month is break-even before card fees. You set the price. I just want you to see the floor.
- Owner What do I tell customers it is for?
- Operator Priority service and tune-ups that never get missed. The discount is a nice extra, not the headline.
- Owner And how do they pay?
- Operator Yearly is cheaper for you. It cuts card fees and sends one payment link, not twelve.
Quick check
- An HVAC plan has 2 tune-ups a year. Each takes 1.5 hours with drive time. Tech cost is $50 an hour. What is the break-even monthly price before card fees?
- $10.00
- $12.50
- $15.00
- $12.00
- An owner wants the plan pitch to say only "15% off every repair." What do you suggest?
- Raise the discount so more customers join
- Lead with priority service and tune-ups that never get missed
- Drop the visits and sell a discount card
- Promise members that almost everyone renews
- Why does yearly billing cost the business less in card fees than monthly billing?
- Card processing is free on yearly payments
- The 30¢ part of the fee is paid once, not twelve times
- ServiceAgent waives card fees on members
- Yearly payments skip the percentage part
ServiceAgent UniversityLearn to run a service business on autopilot. Free courses, Blueprints and certification for Service Operators.